In recent days, the subject of gender and transgenderism have been the talk of our county and our church. Coming, therefore, at the perfect time is Vaughn Roberts little book Transgender. In preparation for my sermon on the subject I read his book with great profit.
In less than 80 pages, Roberts, a British pastor who has himself grappled with same sex attraction, introduces the subject (ch. 1), sets out a biblical response through the framework of creation (ch. 3), fall (ch. 4), and rescue/redemption (ch. 5). He concludes with a chapter on wisdom (ch. 6), where he speaks to individuals and churches on how to lovingly and truthfully respond to our trans neighbors and family members. Still, the chapter that is most important in his book is chapter 2, titled “The iWorld.”
In this section, Roberts frames transgenderism against the backdrop of the Enlightenment and the (post)modernism turn towards the subject. In just a few pages he explains how a recent flurry of advocacy for an age-old condition, i.e., transgenderism (see Deuteronomy 22:5), stems from a Western world head-over-heels in love with the self.
Combined with a contemporary demand for authenticity, radical individualism asserts the right for any individual to define themselves however they choose, even if it contradicts their race (think: Rachel Dolezal), species (men posing as dogs, women as cats, and others as dragons), age (a 55 year old man who identifies as a 6 year old girl) or gender. At present, our country is debating the merits of transgenderism, but Roberts rightly takes us upstream to see the larger, philosophical problem—a cocktail of radical individualism and absolute authenticity brings personal injury and civil disintegration. But what is true of the sexual revolution in public is equally pernicious in the church itself.
Here’s a portion of Roberts survey,
The roots of the profound individualism that marks our culture go back to the period of the Enlightenment 300 years ago, when intellectuals began to assert the primacy of human reason over divine revelation. Most people have never read the works of philosophers like Voltaire and Rousseau, but their influence has gradually trickled down into our whole society so that it affects us all.
The Enlightenment began with great confidence that reason could lead us to the truth, but that optimism gradually disappeared. Even the greatest human thinkers can’t agree on fundamental issues. And so, having rejected revelation and lacking confi- dence in reason, our culture has now largely rejected the concept of objective truth, at least when it comes to big issues, such as meaning and morality.
So where does this leave us? With ourselves as individuals. If we think that truth is subjective, then we certainly won’t let any external authority tell us what to think or how to behave—whether it’s the government, a religion or our family. It’s up to us to draw our own conclusions and live our own lives. As the boys from Boyzone put it in one of their songs:
No matter what they tell you; no matter what they say;
no matter what they teach you; what you believe is true.
All this explains why autonomy is so highly valued today. The iWorld teaches me to resent any challenge to my individualism. As the English philosopher John Stuart Mill, the founding father of modern Western liberalism, wrote:
Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign.
I’m free! Free to think what I want and live as I like. Free to be me. (pp. 25–27)
Is such freedom really free? Roberts following the terrain of Scripture says ‘no.’ And so do I. Jesus said in John 8:32, “If you abide in my word, you will know the truth. And the truth will set you free.” Three observations about Jesus’ words.
- First, they come from Christ himself. While many (on the right and the left) co-opt Jesus for their own social agendas, Jesus is only committed to doing his Father’s will, fulfilling the Law, and teaching his followers truth so that they can know and abide in his love. In short, the call for truth comes from Jesus himself.
- Second, only those who remain, abide, and hold onto the truth will know true freedom. Many are those who grew up in church and left, and many more have come to have a mental understanding of the truth. But only those who cling to the unchanging truth in an ever-changing culture will know freedom.
- Third, freedom is not at odds with truth; freedom is the fruit of truth. While radical individualism invites people to follow their heart, wherever it may lead. Jesus calls people to deny themselves and find freedom, fullness, and life everlasting in him—the one who is the way, the truth, and life.
While our modern individualism and authenticity culture calls people to be free in themselves, however they feel, such freedom comes at a high cost. Instead of building families and communities, it tears them down. The all-important self can congregate with others, but it cannot deny itself in the interest of another. The sexual ethics of the progressive left sounds liberating when it calls for people to be whoever they want to be, but in the end what seems right to a man, woman, or dragon leads to death. Why? Because it turns away from the good purposes of an all-wise God.
Vaughn Roberts exposes this deadly pattern as he writes about our iWorld, and his words ring true for more than those struggling with gender dysphoria. They expose a condition that fills (and is often encouraged) in churches across our country. Accordingly, what we need is not a targeted campaign against the trans community. We need to target to corrosive lies of radical individualism, and to preach a gospel that calls everyone of us to deny himself, pick up his cross, and follow Jesus. For those willing to listen, Vaughn Roberts chapter is a great place to begin.
Lord Jesus, free us from our addiction to self and empower us to do what you command. As Augustine once petitioned, ‘Command what you will, but grant what you command.’
Soli Deo Gloria, ds
4 thoughts on “Transgenderism: But One Fruit on Individualism’s Pernicious Vine”
Thanks for this article. I actually just purchased this book a few days ago. Looking forward to gaining insight from it.
We just bought 25 for our church bookstore. It’s that good and important.
Pingback: Talking Like Jesus: Six Ways to Hold Out Truth in a Hostile World | Via Emmaus
Pingback: A Beautiful Household (pt. 2): Brothers Who Lead, Sisters Who Labor, and a Heavenly Father Who Knows Best | Via Emmaus
Comments are closed.