In theological debate, a plain and straightforward reading of Scripture is often adduced as a compelling “biblical” argument. However, a straightforward reading of Scripture is often in danger of reading the Bible out of context, by truncating or removing texts from their original contexts. In this way, many “biblical” arguments turn out to be exercises in theological redaction and atomistic hermeneutics.
This is the point that Lee Gattis makes in his recent book on the extent of the atonement. He writes,